RSS
Twitter
TIC's Picks: How Can Others Respond To The iPhone
from the iphone-analysis dept
Since it's "iPhone Day," and there have been a ton of stories about the iPhone that focus on the wrong thing ("oh look, shiny new toy!"), we thought it would be good to consider the more important impact that the iPhone will have on the mobile phone ecosystem -- and who better to dive in and provide the analysis than our very own Techdirt Insight Community. As is standard with the diverse group of experts in the Techdirt Insight Community, we received fantastic, detailed, well thought-out analysis that goes a lot deeper than most of what's coming out today. Here is the best analysis from the experts within the community:
- Vinaya.HS explains why it's a mistake for other device makers to simply copy the iPhone, rather than leapfrogging it with new innovations (even though he knows that's where they're heading). He also plays up the benefit of separating the device from the operator (and ending operator subsidies).
- Joe Hunkins explains the two likely strategies that other device makers will follow: trying to catch up and surpass the iPhone's high points, but at a cheaper price point, or giving up on competing and focusing on totally different markets (such as low-end users).
- Derek Kerton has an exceptionally detailed analysis on how the iPhone will end up benefiting everyone -- even competitors and customers who choose not to buy an iPhone.
- Tim Marman focuses on how this could set off a change in distribution methods for mobile phones, as Apple proves that it's possible to do things in a very different way.
- Rafe Blandford highlights the limitations of the iPhone and suggests there's more to learn in how Apple went about marketing the device.
- Steve Litchfield points to the key ease of use features of the iPhone, where simplicity trumps feature creep -- noting how difficult it will be for others to not fall victim to the allure of piling on additional confusing features.
Reader Comments
(Flattened / Threaded)
Does it all go back to itunes?
In reading the marketing article I now see a different face to the reasons behind the iphone. If Apple gets to control the phone and software on the device it could possibly limit ringtone sales by the service provider. So the question becomes does this all go back to Apple trying to maintain a firm grasp over the sale of digital music?
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Re: Does it all go back to itunes?
Could Apple be the next **AA that is doomed to failure as distribution channels become more open and no one corporation/group can control majority access?
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Re: Re: Does it all go back to itunes?
iTunes is pushing to open up. They're being forced to have DRM on their stuff. EMI let them sell DRM-Free stuff and iTunes did so. If the record labels let them sell DRM-Free material, Apple can't have a controlled grasp on the market. You would no longer need to buy an iPod to use iTunes.
As it stands, iTunes is one of the best music stores available. Its easy to use and has an extremely large library. However, Universal may pull out, so that could cause some headaches.
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Fools....
I pity the fools that get suckered into any rotten Apple items... You'll end up getting what you deserve.
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Re: Fools....
Um ok? So I decided my next computer will be a Mac...I guess I deserve not having a headache over the constant crap I receive from Windows.
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Re: Re: Fools....
You'll no longer have to go through the MS headaches. You'll now have another whole bunch of headaches to deal with. And to top that all off with "What Apple Says is what Apple people have to deal with". You're locked in and don't have the freedom of choice us regular PC users have.
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Re: Re: Re: Fools....
I'd rather be locked in to a throne room than free on the top of a cliff with a drop on all sides. But that's my opinion and I don't think less of you for liking your PC.
:)
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Re: Re: Re: Re: Fools....
Why does everyone go to the extreme on both sides? Apple isn't as bad as the pc team says nor is a pc as bad as the mac team says.
seriously, to each their own.
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Motorola A910
Now here was a fine phone for 2005. Yet, no where to be seen today.
Motorola, once again, is gonna get slapped about by Steve Jobs.
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
iPhone.
I have to admit...I am a diehard Apple fan and have not been disappointed by any of their products. That being said, I had exactly zero interest in getting an iPhone having been out of contract for years on Cingular. I went this weekend to check out the phone and I have to say it was awesome. I went home and ordered one up.
But on topic, these was a great series of articles. I'm too stupid to have thought that stuff on my own and it's refreshing to see some insightful news that doesn't originate from either side's camp. Bravo.
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
iPhoneology
Despite the criticism the iPhone is *very, very good* technology - I'd say it's the breakthrough in terms of bringing "decent computing" to a handheld device.
Google's entry should create some powerful competition for similar devices. The big loser here will be Treo. As a user I'm uninspired by the Treo with a too-small screen and poor rural connectivity. They'll have to change their game to adapt to iPhone, and it does not appear that's happening.
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Add Your Comment