Since When Is The Music Industry Anti-Porn?
from the since-it-was-a-backdoor-way-for-them-to-shut-down-file-sharing dept
A bunch of folks submitted this NY Times article that looks at how the music industry has been desperately trying to convince Congress that file sharing networks are a hotbed of pornography and therefore should be regulated. This is nothing new. We covered this story a few months ago when legislation on the topic was first introduced. It’s part of the music industry’s multi-pronged approach to banning file sharing – which they see as evil because they simply refuse to understand what’s really happening. The NY Times piece is fairly balanced, though it includes a few whopper quotes from folks in the music industry: “KaZaA is just like Joe Camel” and “P2P stands for piracy to pornography” being personal favorites. The simple fact is that there is pornography online. People find it all over the place – and a very small percentage do find it through file sharing services. That doesn’t mean there aren’t plenty of legitimate reasons to use file sharing and it doesn’t mean that file sharing systems need special legislation. It’s no different than people using Google to find porn online – but we don’t see the music industry trying to shut down Google (yet). The only thing that’s annoying about all of this is that the folks in Congress are eating this all up and assuming it’s true, without bothering to hear from those who understand what the situation really is. This isn’t surprising, since it’s being supported by folks the music industry put in office, but it is annoying.
Comments on “Since When Is The Music Industry Anti-Porn?”
Funny, that is what I thought the internet was for
Not that I use it for that purpose (as Cox will no doubt attest to, since I use the internet to download Linux and OpenBSD distros, which tend to be far bigger and more bandwidth intensive than porno, which explains why they keep telling me I am going over my monthly quotas,) but I gather, from talking with others that use the Internet, that I am the lone exception to the rule that the Internet is only good for the consumption and distribution of porno.
I suppose next, the RIAA will state that Cable Television is evil because they allow pornography to be displayed on pay channels.
Since when did the RIAA become the Tipper Gore of the 21st century? I am sure John Denver and Frank Zappa are spinning in their graves right now, and Dee Johnson probably isn’t too happy either.