How A School Board In Wisconsin (And The NYC Subway System) Became Accidental Hedge Funds
from the the-obfuscation-of-risk dept
We’ve talked in the past about how one of the causes of the financial crisis was that many banks on Wall Street stopped acting like banks and started acting like hedge funds — despite not really knowing how to do that. That is, they took on much greater risks and higher leverage, without having much of an understanding of how to really hedge that risk. That was fine when all was going well, but when the bubble burst, it started impacting everyone.
Now, in a combined effort between NPR’s Planet Money (I know I’ve said this, but I’ll say it again: if you’re not listening to this every day, you’re missing out, big time) and the NY Times, reports are coming out about how it went well beyond banks turning into hedge funds, to all sorts of other organizations as well. The scary example being described in the first article in this series is how a Wisconsin school board and the NYC subway system, both effectively became hedge funds, lending money out to various banks in exchange for CDOs (collateralized debt obligations). What a CDO is, effectively, is the mashing together of a variety of different debt instruments (loans) that pay out some sort of return. So, you could basically buy some of the return on a whole mess of loans, packaged in all different ways (some amazingly creatively).
If all of those debt instruments that you’re buying into keep on paying, you’re in good shape. If, however, there are defaults, you can be in an awful lot of trouble. However, while everything was going great, defaults weren’t an issue and the folks sold on these CDOs often had no idea how risky they really were. In the article above, for example, the guy who sold the Wisconsin school district on investing $200 million of its pension money in CDOs had only taken a two hour course on them, and greatly downplayed the risks.
And, of course, to make matters even worse, in many cases, the actual risks of such CDOs were hidden through some games, and made worse by either clueless or complicit ratings agencies which rated seriously high risk CDOs as being extremely safe bets. To see a rather graphic (and easily understandable) example of this, I recommend the following Paddy Hirsch video comparing CDOs to pyramids of champagne glasses:
Filed Under: financial crisis, hedge funds, new york, wisconsin
Comments on “How A School Board In Wisconsin (And The NYC Subway System) Became Accidental Hedge Funds”
Greed kills.
Re: Re:
Stupidity kills, greed just gets in the way.
Re: Re:
close. greed causes people to jump off buildings. so it’s more like greed causes you to kill yourself when the cookie crumbles.
WI and NYC Subway Hedge Fund Risks
All the flowering verbiage about creative hedge funds and super used car sales folks disguised as “investment bankers”… it’s actually rather simple; it’s called a ponzie scheme… WI and the NYC Subway are the last guys in line…
Have I got an investment for you
This guy had a whole two hours of training and the school board handed over 2 mil in pension funds. Did they ever hear of “doing your homework” ?
It is almost worse than falling for the 419 scam.
There's a great animation of CDOs here:
http://www.portfolio.com/interactive-features/2007/12/cdo
It’s interesting that the graphic was made in December 2007, almost a year ago.
Fair warning, anyone?
Re: There's a great animation of CDOs here:
They all knew this was coming.
I worked for Wamu as a Wholesale Account Manager in 2006 and I saw this coming.
Paulson and the bunch were/are protecting their “fiends in kind”.
Frankly im getting tired of this
Too many people running around crying about not knowing what they were getting into (I know many personally). I dont know what kind of idiot invests his money in something he doesnt understand, I also cannot imagine the stupidity of someone who borrows money to invest in something he doesnt understand, and I certainly think that people who borrow and invest OTHER peoples money in things they dont understand are far too stupid to be on this earth with the rest of us. When these munnies start firering the morons that “didnt know” what they were getting into when making these deals, then I will believe someone has actually learned from this. Until then, it just looks like plain ole greedy buyers remorse to me.
5 Districts, not 1
Multiple WI school districts are involved:
http://www.jsonline.com/news/education/29431514.html
Re: 5 Districts, not 1
Risk? What risk is there if you can force the taxpayers to bail you out? None! So why shouldn’t they make risky investments? It’s no skin off their backs when it sinks.
Great Information
Great information thanks for sharing. It’s nice to know what we’re all buying $700 billion plus of through the government.