Apple Smacked Down For Calling iPhone 3G "Really Fast"
from the define-really-and-define-fast dept
An ad for the iPhone 3G has been banned in the UK, after the country's advertising regulator decided that calling the device "really fast" four times in an ad was making deceptive claims about the speed with which it could access the internet. Earlier in the year, Apple had another iPhone ad banned after it said it could access "all parts of the internet." The regulator's action was prompted by 17 complaints from consumers about the ad, though at least one of those who complained after he'd received some poor customer service from Apple says revenge was a factor, and wonders if others had similar motivation. While plenty of complaints about Apple in online forums get ignored or shouted down by the legions of Mac fanboys, at least one guy found a way to make his stick.
Carlo Longino is an expert at the Insight Community. To get insight and analysis from Carlo Longino and other experts on challenges your company faces, click here.
Reader Comments (rss)
(Flattened / Threaded)
I am of two minds on this. On the one hand I like the fact that Apple isn't able to just get away with everything. I don't want it to become another Microsoft and see the OS go down the drain.
On the other hand I see an incredible fuss being made every time anything seems to not work perfectly. This may be a little biased, but I think Apple gets blamed for mistakes a lot more and a lot faster than any company. Probably partly their fault, they are one of the best known companies around now, with their ad campaigns.
But I think we just don't make nearly as big a deal of lawsuits like this hitting Dell or IBM. And although the fanboys can be very... energetic in their opinions, a fanbase does not appear for nothing.
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
iphone.. eveything on net ??
except at least the flash part, hmmm pretty big hunk of net, and i think silverlight too... so here we go... that's the "revenge" part ?
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
An angry customer is an angry customer, no matter the motivation.
But this seems a fairly cut&dry situation, with an advertiser misrepresenting the abilities of their product and getting smacked on the nose for it.
Speed is an important product feature in mobile net devices. If you bought a car after watching it zoom about in an advert only to find it only did 30mph, you might feel a bit cheated too.
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Ratio
According to the numbers, Apple is selling an average of 27,000 iPhones in the UK... PER WEEK. That works out to be roughly a half million phones since launch.
And they've had 17 complaints.
Wow. Makes me wonder why didn't you file this story under the making-something-out-of-practically-nothing department?
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
the complaints were about the adds not the product.
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Re:
This wasn't about something not working perfectly, it was about an advertiser indicating their product could do something it could not. There was no lawsuit. Visit http://www.asa.org.uk/asa/about/ for information on the organization responsible.
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
How is a relativistic claim a problem?
As I'm currently traveling in London, I'm seeing the iPhone ads on TV with a disclaimer something to the effect of "sequence and speed has been accelerated", or some such legalese.
If they want to go after Apple because the *NETWORK* cannot possibly function as fast as the events necessary to be squeezed into a :30 spot, that's one thing. It's entirely another to go after them for a relativistic statement like "really fast" As compared to what? My old 1st gen HTC WinMo phone? Abso-friggin-lutely! As compared to my desktop on a hard-wired gigabit Ethernet connection? Well, sure... but that's not the point here, is it?
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
excellent analysis
Hi Thom,
I like how you articulate your views, and substantiate them with researched facts and context. Would you be interested in having people read your analysis? If so, email me at hannahh.kelly@gmail.com
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Re: How is a relativistic claim a problem?
It's not about speed, you dolt.
It's about realistic performance. This is why the smart folks don't use intel, the smart folks don't use vista, etc. However, some do get frauded by a fraud ad like apple's.
Lets use your example. If they said its way faster than an HTC, nobody would have said squat. In fact, it'd probably have been a more effective advertisement.
If you claim your car can go up to 200 miles per hour when the real max speed is around 120 and don't mention that the "max" is on a downhill, well gee, maybe it can only go as fast as it will go (which might be, say considerably less).
Essentially even if your Iphone was on a LAN your performance would not match what they did in a commercial. For this occurrence, someone managed to make the complaints about fraudulent advertising known. It's not unlike those McDonalds commercials that use plastic glazed sandwiches to look "amazing" are the same as the real ones, just nobody has been as successful at putting them to the same standard of honesty.
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Re: How is a relativistic claim a problem?
It wasn't about a statement, it was about showing the phone doing things like downloading google street maps instantaneously.
A tech-savy person would probably see it as an exaggeration (and ignore it as such), but there are plenty of people out there who don't know any better and would buy it believing that possible.
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
IPhone commercials
Has any of you seen the disclaimer that flashes by in the ad foprs the IPHone at least here in the states. It says something like some parts of the operations have been cut out for the purpous of this commcercial meaning that they left several things like waiting for he internet to load and other things you have to do to get the same result they show in the commercial to make it look quick! everyone of you IPHOne users deserve what they get. All this oooohh aaaahh stuff theys how you has been available for years but most of you are to dumb to fgind this kind of functionality so you have to have Jobs show you to the water. Cattle!!!
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
It wasn't the claim, it was the demo
The ad itself and the words they use weren't the problem. The problem was the fact it showed the phone doing a number of different tasks in :28 when it wasn't actually possible.
The showing of an impossible scenario is what the Advertising Standards Council said was misrepresentative.
PCPro duplicated the tasks using an iPhone connected to Wifi and it took almost three minutes to actually do the tasks shown. Here's the video of the recreation.
http://www.pcpro.co.uk/news/239556/what-the-banned-iphone-advert-should-really-look-lik e.html
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Apple torches
This ad smack down seems a bit odd. We let a lot of misleading ads get through in the US... maybe overseas they are a bit more strict on these things?
But Apple always tout how they are super mega ultra best and how their products are top notch and flawlesss... really just their brand name not living up to the brand and hype. They are unfairly scrutinized and I take stones thrown at apple with a grain of salt but they sort of brought it on themselves. Everyone expects Microsoft to screw up... but Apple claims they never do.
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Simpsons
I enjoyed watching the Simpsons mock apple last night. Didn't like the islamic propaganda, but the apple mocking was funny.
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
UK Safety Police: Keep away from the iphone! They're lying to you!
Only 17 complaints? I wonder if this complaint may have come from a competing network who doesn't have the phone on their network.
Is it a case of "If you can't compete, silence them"?
iPhone has 80% of the high-end smartphone market, and has around 95% satisfaction and 80% of owners will recommend it to others. Those numbers are nothing short of incredible. From a organic, word-of-mouth advertising perspective, it's virtually impossible to compete with those numbers.
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Re: Apple torches
That's exactly what I was thinking. Almost every commercial on US TV is misleading & wrong. At least overseas there is a little bit of oversight on the "tele". We are supposed to have truth in advertising but that is not the case. If there is truth they put it on the bottom of the screen where it is shown for a second & in a very small font that no one can read or it is read very quickly similar to the pharmaceutical ads.
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Re: UK Safety Police: Keep away from the iphone! They're lying to you!
If there is one complaint and its found to be justified, they investigate.
And FUD about other networks isn't helping, fanbot.
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Why so heated?
Why is everyone getting so wound up about the iphone and how it is advertised? So what if they demonstrate the functionality and 'omit' the downtime to illustrate the end product? Everyday in life we, the general public, are subjected to unrealistic advertising on TV...singing cows, cars travelling 200 miles in the time it takes to run an average ad etc. Do we get over-heated about them? In our home, myself, partner and our 2 sons all have the iphone 3G and cannot believe how good it actually is. The harshest critics of new technology are teenagers and early 20 somethings - our sons fall into these categories, one of whom is an IT wiz, and everyday they find something new to do with the iphone. Lighten up people...its a new generation of mobile comms; embrace it as such.
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Re:
The complaints are about the fact the product doesn't work like it does in the ad - are you just trying to be obtuse?
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
I find my phone to be about as fast as it is in the commercial when I'm on Wi-Fi, meaning that they aren't really misrepresenting the phone's speeds, but they are misrepresenting the network's speeds. I don't believe they say anywhere in the ad they are on the 3G network, they just imply the phone transmits and receives data over the 3G network.
But advertising has always been this way, the product is rarely as good as the ad says it is. Will the UK begin to attack McDonalds because their burgers never look as good at the restaurant as they do in the ads?
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
I find my phone to be about as fast as it is in the commercial when I'm on Wi-Fi, meaning that they aren't really misrepresenting the phone's speeds, but they are misrepresenting the network's speeds. I don't believe they say anywhere in the ad they are on the 3G network, they just imply the phone transmits and receives data over the 3G network.
But advertising has always been this way, the product is rarely as good as the ad says it is. Will the UK begin to attack McDonalds because their burgers never look as good at the restaurant as they do in the ads?
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
In other news...
...other products from the US "May" cause an erection lasting 4 hours.
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Re: IPhone commercials
what the hell did you just say? Man you nede to lern teh inglish langage.
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Re: Re: How is a relativistic claim a problem?
You know, your the reason why we have to listen to 15 seconds of a 30 second commercial of speed reading legalese to make sure their butt is covered.
I hate those speed readers.
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Re: Why so heated?
I just saw an ad my son is watching for the wonder pets show.
I DEMAND my pet baby duck says, "This is serious" at least once every half hour.
DAMM YOU FALSE ADVERTISERS FOR NOT MAKING MY DUCKS TALK ENGLISH!!!
See how silly that is? I agree. People need to lighten up.
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Re: UK Safety Police: Keep away from the iphone! They're lying to you!
Define "high-end smartphone market"?
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Just an interesting little factoid I thought I'd throw out. Did you know that the average person is exposed to over 12,000 pieces of advertising per day? In one form or another, direct or indirect, large or small.
Maybe we should cut back a little on the marketing, eh? ;)
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Brand new mobile phone , laptop , come with complete
accessories with one year international warranty.
Emaill address: applemac-inc@hotmail.com
HTC TOUCH PRO2..............$500USD
Sony Ericsson Idou Black Unlocked GSM..$550usd
Samsung i8910 Omnia HD Unlocked..$500usd
HTC Touch HD ..........$500usd
HTC Touch Pro ..........$400usd
HTC Touch Diamond ...$350usd
Samsung omnia i900.....$400usd
Apple iphone 3G 16gb........$300usd
Sony ericsson C905.........$500usd
Nokia n96 16gb...$500usd
Apple iphone 16gb..$350usd
Sony ericsson xperia x1..$400usd
Apple iphone 8gb.....$300usd
Nokia n95 8gb.......$300usd
Ps3 60gb.............$300usd
16GB APPLE IPHONE ITEM IN BOX:
iPhone
Stereo Headset
Dock
Dock Connector to USB Cable
USB Power Adapter
Documentation
Cleaning/polishing cloth
User guide
Travel Charger
Leather Case
We make shipment via Ups and Fedex shipping company 2days
deliver worldwide.
If you are interested in buying our product contact us via
Email address: applemac-inc@hotmail.com
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
for sale brand new mobile phones
We are authorise mobile phones,laptops, and video games distributors. We deal on brand
new original unlocked mobile phones.Our prices are wholesale prices and we can
send to you on request.We operate a 100% return policy withing 90 days and we
are commited to our customers satisfaction and happiness. We render quality and
effective services and We are working with fear of GOD, You can never regret
doing business with us. You can contact us via email for more information.
"Buy 3 items and get 1 free
MSN MESSENGER
================
phonesplaza@hotmail.com
bestmobile001@hotmail.com
Contact Name: Mario Vasquez
ORDER INFORMATION :
Shipping Method : FedEx and UPS.
Delivery Time : 2/3 Days.
HERE ARE SOME OF OUR NEW OFFER AVAILABLE IN STORE NOW:
======================================================
*Nokia N97.........................$400
*Nokia 6260 slide......................$350
* Nokia 5800 XpressMusic...................$350
* Nokia 5030 XpressMusic...................$350
*Nokia E63.......................................$330
*Sony Ericsson Idou.........................$500
*Sony ericsson C905.........$500usd
*O2 XDA Guide........................$350
*Samsung i8910 Omnia HD Unlocked...............$500usd
*samsung s5230........................350
* Samsung S9402 Ego..................$350
* Samsung M7500 Emporio Armani...........$350
*Samsung i8510 INNOV8............$330
*Samsung S3030 Tobi...............$350
* Sonim XP3 Enduro.....................$400
* Motorola VE66........................$300
*HTC Touch HD ..........$500usd
*HTC Touch Diamond ...$350usd
*HTC Touch Pro 2.......................$400
* LG Incite................................$350
*LG KP500 Cookie.....................$350
* LG KF900 Prada........................$330
* Sony Ericsson S302...................$300
* BlackBerry Curve 8900............$350
* BlackBerry Storm 9500.............$350
APPLE IPHONES
===================
Apple Iphone 3g 16GB $ 350
Apple Iphone 32GB $ 300
Apple Iphone 16GB $ 280
Apple Iphone 8GB $ 200
Apple Iphone 4gb $ 170
NOKIA MOBILE PHONES
========================
Nokia N97 With 32GB..............$400
Nokia N96 With 16GB ..............$300usd
Nokia 6260 slide......................$350
Nokia 8800 Gold Arte..............$300
Nokia E63.....................$330
Nokia 5800 XpressMusic...................$350
Nokia N95 With 8GB.........$280usd
GAME CONSOLE
===========================
XBoX 360 Premium console ... ..200usd
XBoX 360 pal verrsion..........$170usd
Nintendowii.....................200usd
Nintendo wifi..........$220usd
Ps2.............................160usd
Playstation 3 20GB..............150usd
Playstation 3 60GB..............250usd
Playstation 3 80GB...........$200
PSP...................$60
Xbox 360.................. $100
Nintendo Wii ...............$100
We fast delivery via UPS and FedEx shipping company 2 days
Providing OK
E-mail us back if you are interested in buying our product:
For information
==============
MSN MESSENGER
================
phonesplaza@hotmail.com
bestmobile001@hotmail.com
Contact Name: Mario Vasquez
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Brand new Unlocked Apple iphone 3gs forsale
We have Apple iphone 3gs 32gb for $350usd...
1)Flash player support
2)Quick back option without going to home screen while switching between apps.
3)File browsing and storing
4)Option to attach images, file etc from email app itself.
5)Multiple signature options
6)Manual rotate gesture option
7)Notes app should be more powerful word process (fonts, text size etc)
8)All Grouping of contacts for test message e.g. friend and family groups.
9)App for grouping key social networking sites(for posting universal photos, text to all social networking sites together.
10) Auto spell check in safari browser (like mozilla) when adding text in twitter, facebook leaving comments at blog etc.
11)Build in Flash in camera for night photo shot
12) Front facing camera for video Chat
13) Use cover flow for using multitasking third party apps (limit to 5 apps, not to drain the battery life)
14)Thin quick time player app to run video downloaded from web.
15)Group notification alert or not attended tasks(missed MMS, SMS, PHONE, Chat message, meeting, event etc)on single screen.
Email: tlainc@hotmail.com
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Apple iPhone 3G S (Speed) Quadband 3G HSDPA GPS Unlocked Phone (SIM Free)
Brand new Mobile phone Plasma tv , Laptop game at cheap price come with complete accessories with one year international warranty.
Email address : mediapoints_21@live.com
3G S APPLE IPHONE 16GB...........$450USD
3G S APPLE IPHONE 32GB...........$500USD
PACKAGE BOX INCLUDE:
iPhone 3G S
Stereo Headset with mic
Dock Connector to USB Cable
USB Power Adapter
Documentation
Cleaning/polishing cloth
SIM eject tool
WE MAKE SHIPPMENT VIA UPS OR FEDEX EXPRESS OR DHL EXPRESS IN 2 DAYS AFTER CONFIRMATION OF PAYMENT......
Email address : mediapoints_21@live.com
mediapoints_21@yahoo.com
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Add Your Comment