Current Insight Community Cases

Essential Datacenter Tips On Application Performance Monitoring

The Importance Of Skilled Immigrants To The American Economy

Help A New Kind of Music Label Revolutionize The Industry

Mandates To Buy American Should Be More Carefully Considered

Navigating The New Business World After This Recession

Shut Us Up

-- For Only $100 Million

Brought to you by Floor64 and the Techdirt crew.

stories about: "acer"
Computers

Computers

by Mike Masnick


Filed Under:
contracts, netbooks, subsidies, wireless broadband

Companies:
acer, at&t, radio shack



Subsidized Laptops With Locked In Wireless Broadband Contracts

from the good-or-bad? dept

A few years back, after noting the trend of laptop companies to start building in cellular data modems into their laptops, we wondered when it would reach the stage where mobile operators would subsidize the cost of a laptop, just as they subsidize the cost of mobile phones in many cases. In early 2006, we started to see such subsidized laptops go on sale in Europe, with the mobile operators selling the laptops directly for well below list price, as long as you bought into a long term data plan. The whole idea seemed a bit strange, as mobile operators have long ranted long and hard about how much they hate, hate, hate subsidies, and how they wish they could do away with them. So, why add them to laptops?

However, the idea has now traveled over to the US as well, in a deal between Acer, Radio Shack and AT&T allowing people to buy an Acer netbook for just $100, so long as they agree to a 2 year $60/month contract for an AT&T mobile data plan. It's still a little confusing as to why the mobile operators are agreeing to this, following so many vehement arguments against mobile phone subsidies, but perhaps they're finally realizing that those subsidies aren't such a bad thing when they get people using their services. Still, how long will it be until buyers start complaining about early termination fees for laptops like they do for mobile phones?

24 Comments | Leave a Comment..

 
Legal Issues

Legal Issues

by Mike Masnick


Filed Under:
patents, wifi

Companies:
acer, apple, best buy, broadcom, circuit city, dell, intel, lenovo, sony, texas instruments, wi-lan



Wi-LAN Follows New Patent Hoarder Strategy: Sue Everyone All At Once

from the this-is-innovation? dept

Three and a half years ago, I wrote an article about the coming WiFi patent problem, focusing on the Canadian company Wi-LAN who claimed a bunch of patents related to WiFi technology. The company started off by suing Cisco. That lawsuit was eventually settled, but Wi-LAN clearly wasn't done yet. The company has now sued 22 different companies for violating its patents. This strategy seems to be the new strategy of patent holders: sue a ton of high profile companies all at once. It's what Sandisk did for example. Why is it becoming more popular? Because these patent holders are afraid that one of the potential targets might sue them first, seeking a declaratory judgment saying they don't infringe, and do so in a court other than the patent friendly court in Marshall, Texas. Oh yeah, Wi-LAN also notes that it's more economical to sue everyone at once. How nice of them.

Of course, Wi-LAN is hardly the only company that claims patents having to do with WiFi. It's a true patent thicket. If all these patents were actually valid and needed to be licensed no one could afford WiFi and it would be worthless. It's also worth noting that Wi-LAN's target list is somewhat ridiculous as well. It appears to be suing up and down the supply chain from chip suppliers like Broadcom and Intel to computer makers like Apple, Dell, Lenovo and Sony all the way to retailers like Best Buy and Circuit City. Assuming that all are somehow responsible for paying Wi-LAN the company could conceivably get license fees three or four times for the same computer. It's not hard to start adding up the questionable things going on here: (1) broad patents that are claimed to be important for a standard long after that standard has become widespread (2) these patents are one of many, many patents that claim to cover WiFi technology (3) filing the lawsuit against many companies at once (4) filing the lawsuit in east Texas and (5) filing the patents up and down the supply chain. This isn't what the patent system was designed to do and patent attorneys know it.

147 Comments | Leave a Comment..

 
Search Techdirt Wireless
And now, a word from our Sponsors..



Popular Posts
Poll

Which Internet Concern Worries You The Most?

 

 

 

 

 

 


Add Techdirt RSS To Your Reader
rss Add Techdirt to your Bloglines
Add Techdirt to your Google Add Techdirt to your My Yahoo
Add Techdirt to your Netvibes Add Techdirt to your Newsgator
Subscribe to the Techdirt Wireless Newsletter

Techdirt Wireless Email Newsletter

Older Stuff

Tuesday

5:08pm: iPhone To Be Offered From Multiple Carriers, eh (53)
3:24pm: Palm Finally Realizes It Needs To Help, Not Hinder Developers (21)

Friday

6:44pm: The iPhone Is Not The End Of Innovation (55)

Thursday

5:16am: Will People Pay CNN To Help Them Report The News? (81)
12:54am: See, The Palm Pre Can Be Offered For Free (36)

Tuesday

5:28pm: New Zealand Says You Can't Use Your Mobile Phone For Navigation While Driving (16)
12:20pm: Why Apple Should Let Other Devices Connect To iTunes (109)

Wednesday

12:22am: Clearwire Supports Net Neutrality? Does No One Remember Its History? (7)

Tuesday

10:34pm: Why Did Apple Approve Spotify? (16)

Wednesday

9:59am: Content Owners Force Hulu To Block Mobile Browsers As Well (29)

Tuesday

5:02pm: Sprint Offers Palm Pre For $100 For A Month, Maybe Two... Then, Oops, Not At All (19)
8:38am: Recording Industry, Japanese Gov't Work To Break Your Mobile Phone If You Listen To Unauthorized Music (20)

Thursday

3:52pm: Why Sprint Should Be Giving Away The Palm Pre For Free (65)

Friday

4:13pm: Did People Think No One Would Recognize REAL ID If Introduced Under Another Name? (9)

Tuesday

1:17pm: Latest Techno Moral Panic: Texting Is 'Rewiring Young Brains' (28)

Monday

5:34pm: Laptop Magazine Rescinds 'Best Of Show' Award For Zer01 (14)

Tuesday

6:18pm: The Death Of Paid WiFi (46)

Friday

6:37pm: Apple's Google Voice Rejection Wakes Up A Dormant FCC; Investigation Begins (77)
9:24am: iPhone Haters Are Stick-Shifters In An Automatic World (140)

Thursday

8:14am: Is Apple Suggesting That The DMCA Prevents Terrorism? (42)
12:31am: What's Next? Can Senators Ban Stupidity While Driving? (62)

Wednesday

8:28pm: New Mobile Music Service Works Via Voice Calls (9)

Tuesday

3:15am: Apple Says No To Google Voice On The iPhone (64)

Monday

9:22am: Fact Checking? UK Paper Simply Takes The Word Of Guy Who Claims WiFi Allergy (29)
4:59am: Will Apple Allow Spotify On The iPhone? (15)

Thursday

9:12am: Australian Police Start Wardriving; Telling You To Lock Up Your WiFi (45)

Wednesday

4:02pm: The Zer01 Story: Lots Of Buzz, But Is It Actually Real...? (69)

Tuesday

2:41pm: Thin Skin: SMS Political Jokes In Pakistan Can Get You 14 Years In Jail (18)

Friday

3:23pm: RIM Pays Out Again Over Patents (31)

Thursday

1:23am: The Reality: Not As Many Actual Apps In The iPhone App Store As You're Told (26)
More arrow
Quick Links
Close
E-mail It